Marion County’s Most Dangerous Roads: An Analysis of 5,870 Fatal and Serious Injury Crashes in Indianapolis

Home » Blog » Marion County’s Most Dangerous Roads: An Analysis of 5,870 Fatal and Serious Injury Crashes in Indianapolis
Vaughn A. Wamsley
Dollar Box Icon
Hundreds of

Millions recovered

5 start Rating Icon
200+

five-star reviews

Unless we win
No fee

Unless we win

30+ Years of experience
30+ years

Of experience

Marion County's Most Dangerous Roads 2018 to 2026 Crash Data

Marion County recorded 5,870 crashes that killed someone or caused a suspected serious injury between January 2018 and September 29, 2026. I-465 had the most of any road, and Washington Street and 38th Street were the deadliest surface streets. Failure to yield was the leading cause, and pedestrians were involved in more than one in four fatal crashes.

Reviewed by Vaughn A. Wamsley, an Indianapolis personal injury attorney admitted to the Indiana bar in 1988 who has represented injured people for more than 30 years. Last reviewed November 2026.

Most people in Indianapolis have a road they avoid. This study puts numbers behind those instincts. We analyzed every fatal and serious injury crash in the Indianapolis Metropolitan Planning Organization’s location-corrected crash database, which is built from the Indiana State Police ARIES crash reporting system, to identify the roads, causes, and times that produce the most devastating crashes in Marion County.

Key Findings

  • 5,870 fatal and serious injury crashes since 2018. Marion County accounted for 59% of all fatal and serious injury crashes in the eight-county Central Indiana region from January 2018 through September 29, 2026.
  • I-465 tops the list. I-465 was involved in 448 fatal and serious injury crashes in Marion County, including 72 fatal crashes.
  • Washington Street is the deadliest surface street. Washington Street recorded 260 fatal and serious injury crashes, including 59 fatal crashes, and more pedestrian and bicyclist crashes (82) than any other road in the county.
  • Failure to yield is the leading cause. Failure to yield the right of way was the primary factor in 1,207 crashes, more than twice as many as any other factor.
  • Pedestrians are overrepresented in deaths. Pedestrians were involved in 267 of the county’s 992 fatal crashes from 2018 through 2025, or 27%.
  • Weekends are the most dangerous. Saturday (951), Friday (932), and Sunday (884) had the most fatal and serious crashes of any day of the week.
  • Serious crashes peaked in 2024. Marion County recorded 777 fatal and serious injury crashes in 2024, 42% more than in 2018.

Finding 1: Serious Crashes in Marion County Rose 42% From 2018 to 2024

Figure 1. Fatal and suspected serious injury crashes in Marion County by year. 2026 figures run through September 29, 2026.

Marion County recorded 549 fatal and serious injury crashes in 2018 and 551 in 2019. The total jumped to 658 in 2020 and 750 in 2021, and reached a high of 777 in 2024. In 2025, the count fell to 689, still 25% higher than in 2018.

Fatal crashes followed a similar pattern, rising from 105 in 2018 to a high of 145 in 2022 before falling back to 105 in 2025. From 2018 through 2025, Marion County averaged about 124 fatal crashes a year, or more than two every week.

Finding 2: The Most Dangerous Roads in Indianapolis

Figure 2. Marion County roads named in the most fatal and serious injury crashes, January 2018 through September 29, 2026. A crash at an intersection counts toward both roads.

I-465 was involved in more fatal and serious injury crashes than any other road in Marion County, with 448 crashes, including 72 fatal crashes, over the study period. I-65 (240 crashes) and I-70 (239 crashes) ranked third and fourth. High speeds, heavy truck traffic, and frequent lane changes make interstate crashes especially severe, and long-running construction zones have added to the risk. Learn more about why I-65 is so dangerous and how construction zones change fault rules.

Surface streets told a different story. Washington Street, which runs east to west across the entire county, recorded 260 fatal and serious injury crashes and 59 fatal crashes, the most of any non-interstate road. 38th Street followed with 234 crashes and 54 fatal crashes. Both are wide, multi-lane corridors with frequent intersections, commercial driveways, bus stops, and heavy pedestrian activity. Shadeland Avenue stood out for severity: 32 of its 121 serious crashes were fatal, or 26%.

RoadFatal and serious injury crashesFatal crashesCrashes involving a pedestrian or bicyclist
I-4654487221
Washington St2605982
I-652403314
I-70239398
38th St2345458
30th St1693427
10th St1652546
Emerson Ave1542018
Keystone Ave1382118
Shadeland Ave1213234

If you were hurt in a crash on one of these roads, the location itself can matter to your claim. Traffic camera footage, nearby business video, and prior crash history at the same location can all become evidence. Our guide to Indianapolis car accident hotspots and our Indianapolis car accident lawyers page explain how location evidence is used.

Finding 3: Failure to Yield Causes More Serious Crashes Than Anything Else

Figure 3. Primary contributing factors listed by officers in Marion County fatal and serious injury crashes, January 2018 through September 29, 2026.

Officers listed failure to yield the right of way as the primary factor in 1,207 fatal and serious injury crashes, about 21% of the total. Disregarding a traffic signal or sign (522) and unsafe speed (492) also ranked near the top. Right-angle crashes, often called T-bone crashes, were the most common type of collision at 1,228, followed by vehicles running off the road (1,033) and rear-end crashes (781).

These causes point directly to driver error, which matters for injury claims. In a crash caused by failure to yield, speeding, or running a red light or stop sign, the police report, witness statements, and intersection video often establish fault. Indiana’s modified comparative fault rule still allows the other side to argue that you share some of the blame, which is why evidence matters from the first day.

Finding 4: Pedestrians and Bicyclists Account for Nearly a Third of Deaths

Figure 4. Fatal crashes in Marion County by type of road user involved, 2018 through 2025.

From 2018 through 2025, Marion County recorded 992 fatal crashes. Pedestrians were involved in 267 of them and bicyclists in 44, meaning people outside a vehicle were involved in 31% of fatal crashes. Washington Street (82), 38th Street (58), and 10th Street (46) recorded the most fatal and serious crashes involving pedestrians and bicyclists. Our pages on Indianapolis pedestrian accidents and bicycle accidents explain the rights of people hit while walking or riding.

Finding 5: Weekends and Summer Months Are the Most Dangerous

Figure 5. Marion County fatal and serious injury crashes by day of the week, January 2018 through September 29, 2026.

Saturday was the most dangerous day of the week, with 951 fatal and serious injury crashes, followed by Friday (932) and Sunday (884). Nearly half of all serious crashes (47%) happened Friday through Sunday. Tuesday had the fewest (747). By month, August (592), July (585), and May (584) recorded the most crashes, while February recorded the fewest (346).

Darkness also plays a role. While 52% of serious crashes happened in daylight, 45% happened after dark, including 795 on roads with no street lighting.

Finding 6: Serious Crashes Are Rising Faster in the Suburbs

Figure 6. Fatal and serious injury crashes by county in the Indianapolis MPO region, 2018 and 2025.

Marion County still accounts for most serious crashes in Central Indiana, but several surrounding counties are growing faster. From 2018 to 2025, fatal and serious injury crashes rose 47% in Johnson County, 42% in Hendricks County, and 37% in Hamilton County. Within Hamilton County, Fishers (228), Noblesville (225), and Carmel (197) recorded the most serious crashes over the study period. The firm also represents injured people in Carmel, Fishers, and Noblesville.

“I was hit on my bicycle by a drunk driver in 1982 and spent more than three months in the hospital, so I know what one of these crashes does to a person and a family. These numbers are not abstract to me. Every one of them is someone who has to fight an insurance company while they are trying to recover, and they should not have to do that alone.” Vaughn A. Wamsley, Attorney

What to Do After a Serious Crash in Marion County

  1. Call 911 and get medical care right away, even if you feel fine. Some injuries do not show symptoms for hours or days.
  2. If you can, photograph the scene, the vehicles, traffic signals, and road conditions, and get contact information for witnesses.
  3. Request the crash report. Our guide to getting a free police report explains how.
  4. Ask nearby businesses to preserve video before it is recorded over.
  5. Do not give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company before you understand your rights. Learn what to do after an Indianapolis car accident.

Limitations of This Data

  • The data includes only crashes that resulted in a death or a suspected serious injury. Minor injury and property damage crashes are not included.
  • Road totals are based on the road and cross street listed in each crash record. A crash at an intersection counts toward both roads, and roads were not adjusted for length or traffic volume.
  • Primary factors are recorded by the investigating officer at the time of the crash and may not reflect a later finding of fault.
  • 2026 data runs through September 29, 2026, and recent records may still be updated.

Methodology

We analyzed the Indianapolis Metropolitan Planning Organization’s location-corrected crash records for 2018 through September 29, 2026, available through the IMPO Data Portal Crash Data Dashboard. The IMPO builds this dataset from fatal and suspected serious injury crash reports submitted to the Indiana State Police Automated Reporting Information Exchange System (ARIES) and corrects crash locations for accuracy. 

The dataset covers Boone, Hamilton, Hancock, Hendricks, Johnson, Marion, Morgan, and Shelby counties and includes 9,895 crashes. We counted crashes by year, county, city, road, primary factor, manner of collision, crash type, light condition, day of week, and month. Road names were standardized to combine spelling variations, such as directional prefixes and interstate formats.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most dangerous road in Indianapolis?

I-465 was involved in the most fatal and serious injury crashes in Marion County from January 2018 through September 29, 2026, with 448 crashes and 72 fatal crashes. Among surface streets, Washington Street had the most, with 260 crashes and 59 fatal crashes.

How many fatal crashes happen in Marion County each year?

Marion County recorded between 104 and 145 fatal crashes per year from 2018 through 2025, averaging about 124 per year. The county recorded 105 fatal crashes in 2025.

What causes the most serious crashes in Indianapolis?

Failure to yield the right of way was the primary factor in 1,207 fatal and serious injury crashes in Marion County, more than any other cause. Pedestrian actions, disregarding a traffic signal or sign, and unsafe speed followed.

What day of the week has the most serious crashes in Indianapolis?

Saturday had the most fatal and serious injury crashes in Marion County, followed by Friday and Sunday. Nearly half of all serious crashes happened from Friday through Sunday.

How long do I have to file a car accident claim in Indiana?

Indiana generally gives injured people two years from the date of the crash to file a personal injury lawsuit. Claims against government entities have much shorter notice deadlines, so it is important to act quickly.

How much does it cost to hire a personal injury lawyer in Indianapolis?

Vaughn A. Wamsley handles injury cases on a contingency basis, which means there is no fee unless you receive compensation.

Talk to an Indianapolis Personal Injury Lawyer

If you or someone you love was seriously hurt in a crash in Marion County or anywhere in Central Indiana, Vaughn A. Wamsley has spent more than 30 years helping injured people recover fair compensation from insurance companies. There is no fee unless we win. Contact us or call 317-846-1080 for a free consultation.

About the Author

Picture of Vaughn A. Wamsley

Vaughn A. Wamsley

Vaughn A. Wamsley is the founder of the law office of Vaughn A. Wamsley, an Indiana personal injury law firm with offices in Carmel and Indianapolis. Admitted to the Indiana bar in 1988 and to the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Northern Districts of Indiana in 1989, he has spent more than 30 years helping injured people recover fair compensation from insurance companies. He is a sustaining member of the Indiana Trial Lawyers Association and a graduate of Indiana University Bloomington.

View Full Attorney Profile

See What
Your Case Is Worth!

Fields marked with an * are required

Categories
Archives

Protect Your Rights
Before It’s Too Late

Every hour you let pass before calling Vaughn Wamsley after an accident gives the insurance company an advantage. Witnesses’ memories grow foggy, evidence disappears, statutes expire. And if you try to tough it out and hold off on treating an injury, the insurance company will use it against you. Don’t wait.
Call Vaugh now. He wants to hear your story!